The success of any production of the beloved The Sound of Music is always going to hinge on the performance of Maria. In Hannah Charlotte the Melville Theatre Company has found its star who sings the iconic songs beautifully, sets the tone and leads the large company with style, and works seamlessly with the seven Von Trapp children, another barometer of success. Perhaps not quite as successful in depicting the romance with the Captain, it's an impressive performance nonetheless.
There is real charm to the production, driven by Charlotte's portrayal and some lovely turns by the children; notably Quinn Dally as a disarmingly forthright Brigitta, and 9-year-old Halle McDonald who is utterly adorable as Gretl.
Nigel Goodwin is suitably stiff and uptight in the early going as Captain Von Trapp before the character softens on recognising the impact Maria is having on his children. The transition to falling for her isn't quite there but we get swept up in the romance as the storm clouds of an encroaching Nazi Germany gather.
In this it's a musical very much in two halves. The last time I'd seen the stage production was in Melbourne back in 2016 where, I confess, to being totally smitten with Amy Lehpamer as Maria. I'd forgotten though how many classic Rodgers & Hammerstein songs there are in Act One. It's a cavalcade of music theatre standouts - the title song, How Do You Solve A Problem Like Maria?, My Favourite Things, Do-Re-Mi, Lonely Goatherd, and Climb Every Mountain. It also strikes me, after recently seeing a modern musical which is relentlessly paced, how stately this is. It takes its time as it unfolds memorable song after memorable song with the story interspersed throughout. You sit back and savour the result.
The second act, for me, isn't as successful because it gets a little bogged down in plot mechanics as politics and the subsequent threat to the Von Trapp family grows. Musically, there are a lot of reprises to those first act tunes leaving Edelweiss as the most notable song. We'll get back to that later.
This is a huge community theatre production with 22 listed cast members along with 13 Nuns and 3 Postulants. The roles of Marta and Gretl, the two youngest children, have alternates. So a company of forty. This lends the show a sense of scale and provides vocal depth and, in the case of the show opening Preludium, great beauty with so many voices in harmony.
Director Neroli Sweetman has extensively used the floor space in front of the stage and the central steps leading up to it, again to give a sense of scale and spectacle. Guests in the second act party scene are stationed on either side of the floor; Liesl (Escher Roe) and Rolf (David Bell) sing the sweet Sixteen Going on Seventeen in front of the stage, left; the foot of the stage and stairs are utilised for the impossibly cute So Long Farewell. We even had three Nazis sitting next to us in the front row for the Kaltzburg concert!
The stage itself is well appointed with sumptuous furniture and rear screen backdrops to depict the Von Trapp household and, of course, the hills. Indeed, there is as large a number of designers and crew to support the size of the show, including two people listed for Continuity which is hardly surprising given the logistics involved. Musical Director Nick Navarra has used a backing track for the music which is sometimes a little too overpowering as it swells in grandeur, however, it has allowed him to focus on the vocal performances which are, mostly, excellent with one curious exception.
Costume Coordinator Michelle Sharp has handled the task of costuming so many performers in so many styles with aplomb. From the more austere habits of the nuns to the clever evolution of the children's clothes as Maria's influence takes hold, to the opulence of the guests, practicality of the servants, and the severe trim of the Germans. It truly is shocking to see a swastika armband which is entirely the point.
Sound by Mack Chidlow is generally good, however, microphone pickup was occasionally slow, especially in the larger numbers. Then there's the situation I didn't quite understand - Goodwin's mic was fine for dialogue but was surprisingly underpowered for his vocals. His singing, therefore, came across as tentative. I wasn't sure if that was because of the volume disparity or the volume disparity was because his singing wasn't as strong as certainly Charlotte's though he fared better in harmonies. It unfortunately cruelled Edelweiss which should have been an emotionally resonant moment.
Other performers to catch the eye - Eilish Marie Blackmore as an empathetic Mother Abbess who guides Maria back to the Von Trapps and handles the challenge of the first act closer well; Peter Shaw and Imogen Porter as Franz and Frau Schmidt respectively who quietly add a little levity to proceedings until the mood turns as the Anschluss is enacted; Esher Roe as the oldest child Liesl in a lovely portrayal that couldn't be more removed from a role she played earlier in the year; and Darren Goodison who flirts with being too preening as Max Detweiler yet made me laugh with his "flowers and a certificate" shtick towards the end.
This is a well-presented production of a perennial classic. Fans of the movie will lap it up. There were people happily singing along all around me. The scenes and songs featuring Hannah Charlotte and the children are simply a delight. Shout out to Choreographer Matilda Jenkins and Sweetman for staging these moments with obvious affection. A charming time at the theatre.
The Sound of Music is on at the Civic Centre Main Hall, Almondbury Road, Booragoon until 30 November.
Cast photos by Curtain Call Creatives
